Navigating the vast sea of content is an adventure that I sometimes like to call Streaming in Rebootland and it makes it easy to miss things. And with the fractured marketing avenues now—I mean, how many people are watching live TV and sitting through commercials or going to the movies and watching trailers?—it’s gotten harder and harder to even know what’s out there. So while there’s so much content available, we end up streaming Brooklyn Nine Nine or Parks and Recreation again and wondering why there’s nothing to watch. So I’m here to tell you about a show that I missed when it came around and just concluded its fourth and final season, Evil.
Evil follows a team of assessors, who are basically investigators who analyze unexplained events for the Catholic Church. But it’s not what you think—the head of the team is David Acosta, played by Mike Colter (Luke Cage, Plane), an aspiring priest with a past, but his team is rounded out by tech expert and skeptic former Muslim Ben Shakir, played by Aasif Mandvhi (The Daily Show) and their tether to the real world of psychology, atheist/lapsed Catholic Dr. Kristen Bouchard, played by Katja Herbers (Westworld, Manhattan), who often acts as a psychological expert witness for the New York DA. Not only is she the linchpin of the team, she’s arguably the star of the show. She and her four daughters, anyway. Now, a lot of these unexplained events take the shape of some sort of demonic possession they need to come in, figure out, and then resolve. It has that monster-of-the-week structure with an overarching story that strings them all together, where they deal with a new problem just about each episode, but there are connections being made all the time. Working the other side of the aisle is Leland Townsend, played by Michael Emerson (Lost, Person of Interest), who works against Kristen both in the courtroom and out of it. Aptly described as a psychopath, Townsend is, at least for the first season, which is what I’ve seen thus far, the primary antagonist of the show.
I admit to having a hard time with shows like this and that comes down to my own biases. Media is so entrenched in Christian iconography that it feels inescapable. Take vampires, for example. Why do they respond to some religious symbols and not to others? The mythology there is inherently implying that one religion is right. The Bible shows up in Jeopardy! categories all the time and unlike my resistance to learning where rivers are (come on, they all end up in oceans anyway, what’s the point of learning the rivers?), I grew up with a big handicap on learning Bible stuff. It can be othering. I resisted watching Father Brown for the longest time for the same reason, but I’m glad I caved because that is a wonderfully uplifting cozy mystery show that has no interest in proselytizing. And so far, neither does Evil. By composing the team the way they have, the show focuses heavily on real world explanations for claims of demonic possession and hauntings and the like and continues to keep not just the characters, but the audience, guessing as to what is happening and what isn’t. Through the first season, it’s kept ambiguous—after all, a lot what might have once been called demonic possession has been explained by advances in science and mental health, and the show is quick to point that out. So you’re often kept from knowing exactly what is going on—is a killer’s case one of a desperate legal play at insanity or lesser sentencing, is it is a case of psychosis manifesting as demonic possession due to the pervasiveness of religious iconography or their upbringing, or is it real demons puppeteering the actions of ordinary people in the real world who otherwise wouldn’t have done anything as sinful as shoplifting a pack of gum? Perhaps the answer to that will come, but so far, I’ve been enjoying not knowing the show’s stances.
What follows is a show that feels much more like the spiritual successor, excuse the pun, to The X-Files, more so than the mystery box in a mystery box (in another mystery box made out of mystery boxes) that was Fringe and even more so than the actual X-Files reboot attempt. Except, instead of unwavering belief in the extraterrestrial and paranormal, it’s a belief in the religious supernatural that frames the conflicts. And the skeptics are put at the forefront of the storytelling. Kristen’s job is to find the scientific explanation for what’s going on. Ben’s job is to analyze any sort of evidence that may be obscuring the truth. There are times that Ben feels like the Professor from Gilligan’s Island, where he is able to just take care of the things or fills in knowledge of things that don’t fall anywhere on the Kristen/David Venn diagram. So not only can he analyze digital footage for evidence of tampering, he can also trace hacks and test kitchen and bathroom fixtures for contaminants that may be causing heavy metal poisoning, and he knows his way around pharmaceuticals and is very observant. Someone has to do it, but he’s more than a perfunctory character. He often seems to get the short straw of the work here and his character has thus far been less of a focus than Kristen or David, but he still has an important role to play and Mandvi does a good job with it, playing against type. While he may provide the majority of the comic relief here, his role is a serious one and he’s not just playing a jokester—in fact, some of the claimed demons offer more laughs, especially with their mundane names like George and Roy (I mean, would you be worried about taking on George in Diablo IV the same way you’re worried about fighting characters named Mephisto and The Wandering Death?). He’s self assured and competent in a way you don’t usually see comedians play and to see representation of a Muslim-born atheist who is just a normal guy goes a long way to making someone like me feel seen in a television landscape where that doesn’t usually exist. I hope to see his character deepen in later seasons, because I think there’s a lot there that we just haven’t seen yet. Emerson, on the other hand, after his socially awkward hero turn in Person of Interest, returns to playing type as the creepy and, well, evil guy who aims to sow chaos and despair at every chance he gets. His venom drips from the screen when he wants it to and turns it off when the situation calls for it.
If we continue with the X-Files analogy, David is the Mulder of the team. The true believer. Though he’s had his troubles in the past, he found his path through the world in the form of training to be a priest and somehow fell into this line of work where he’s putting himself in the line of fire constantly and more than occasionally getting himself into exorcisms, which seem much more intense than the ones Bob Larson teaches people to do. But despite his faith, it’s not blind—he’s a nuanced character with doubts and feelings just like any other person would have. Even though he truly believes in the power of his religion and his god, he doesn’t let it blind him to secular causes for unexplained happenings. I was very impressed with the way Mike Colter plays David, not just with his Luke Cage intensity, but also with humility and devotion to the truth, not just to his religion. But the real star of the show here is the Scully, newcomer to the team Kristen. A self-professed atheist and lapsed Catholic, she joins Ben in his skepticism and comes at it from a psychological perspective. It’s not like I’ve calculated screen time, but we spend a lot of time with Kristen and her four daughters, whom she raises with the help of her mother while her husband is away climbing mountains in Nepal. Her kids are endearingly cacophonous in a way that’s properly kid-like. They talk a lot and talk over each other—I mean constantly, they all talk at the same time almost all the time—but Kristen’s parent ear is far more trained than mine and she’s able to tell what they’re saying even if I get lost in the chatter. Played the wrong way, they could have been annoying, but more than anything, you just see some adorable kids who are, unfortunately, being put in danger and you just want to see them protected. Annoying kids can ruin a show, but these little buggers enhance it and really make you care about their wellbeing. Kristen, much like David, is a complicated and fully realized character; she used to be a mountain climber herself, but now focuses on her work and raising her kids while her husband does the climbing (whether it’s a second source of income or he’s just an absentee father isn’t really clear to me, but either way, he’s not around). Her scientific beliefs are often at odds with her religious upbringing and she’s clearly conflicted by what she’s doing, but deems it both important and practical. After all, with four children and a husband off re-enacting that scene from Mission: Impossible 2, a steady income is pretty important, especially when she’s still paying off student loans.
And one of the more surprising things about this show—even though it’s this thing about devils and demons—is that there are real world, practical concerns that are in touch with our reality as well. It’s not hard to imagine the state of the world in the grips of some sort of evil—whether it be supernatural, too common run-of-the-mill depravity, or something else entirely, we are surrounded by evil acts everyday. The reason behind them may be debated and has been for centuries, so I’m hardly going to solve it in the span of one blog post, but when you see the world of Evil, it’s very easy to see ours in it. And the show is keen to remind us that it’s meant to exist in our world, bringing up big topics like generational trauma, the echoes of slavery, and more. But perhaps the most surprising thing about Evil is how much it doesn’t feel like an exclusionary show. I’m sure there is quite a bit of religious symbolism I’m missing, but there’s some I’ve caught and the series has a definite color theory and so much of the way the show is presented feels very considered and intentional. While there’s a lot of Catholicism here, it’s not so mired in ritual and tradition that I need a Catholic-to-nonbeliever dictionary like I did with Conclave (which is an excellent movie, by the way; definitely see it if you haven’t yet), and in the first season, it never takes a side fully. In The X-Files, we the viewer know that there are aliens and the ghosts and the like the Scully is always just too late to see that they are real, but in Evil we can never be sure of what we’re seeing. Dream sequences, psychoses, lies—the show itself acts as an unreliable narrator and keeps you seeing, in some ways, what you want to see, and also keeps you veiled in the mystery of the overarching story. Did the team cure a demonic possession through exorcism? Or did the act of the ritualistic exorcism free a person of a genuinely held belief in their own possession?
It’s far from the cozy mystery of Father Brown’s quaint English countryside, but it’s nonetheless a show somehow brings comfort. After all, no matter the root cause of evil, whether it’s supernatural, paranormal, or just sadly normal, there is comfort in knowing that there are good people willing to stand up and do something about it. I’ve said many times that I love to see shows and movies about good people doing good things, especially as the real world becomes increasingly chaotic, divided, and violent, and Evil delivers that in a way I really didn’t expect. Each episode ends with a kinetic cliffhanger that leaves you wanting more—I generally try to space TV shows out so I don’t burn through them and then have to wait years for the next season like I’m doing with Stranger Things, but I can’t stop myself from watching episode after episode, going through the entire first season in just two days.
I wish I had found this show while it was still airing, but I’ve read that even though it was cancelled after just four seasons, it was given an extended final arc in order for the series to have a satisfying ending. And while I am dreading getting to the end and no longer having this genuinely enjoyable show to watch anymore, I’m excited to see how it concludes. And luckily, Evil is available for streaming on both Netflix and Paramount+, though Netflix doesn’t have the fourth season yet. If you were a fan of The X-Files or want some spooky mysteries to solve along with some properly good characters, I highly recommend giving Evil a try. The show, not the concept.